Charles Sylvestre's Victim Wins $610K Judgment

April 27, 2011

Beckett Personal Injury Office In Downtown London's article image

LONDON, Ont. -- A former victim of notorious pedophile priest Charles Sylvestre has won a landmark victory in her quest for justice against the London diocese of the Roman Catholic Church.

Chatham woman Kelly Murphy-Myers, 41, was awarded a $610,000 judgment on Thursday as a result of her lawsuit against the diocese — the first lawsuit by a Sylvestre victim to reach trial.

Justice T. David Little wrote in his decision that the hierarchy of the diocese “had to know about Sylvestre’s propensities,” and was negligent in taking no or inadequate steps before appointing him pastor of the parish of St. Ursula’s in Chatham in 1968.

“There was a cover-up by the diocese. There was a cover-up by the Roman Catholic Church itself,” Little wrote. “The cover-up was for the benefit of the diocese and the Church, at the expense of the victim.”

The court heard that the abuse took place in the late 1970s, when Murphy-Myers was between the ages of seven and 10.

Her lawyer, Rob Talach, said the judge’s decision represents the highest level of court to award a female victim of abuse by a Catholic priest in Canadian history.

Talach said the decision will set a precedent for future judgments in abuse cases involving clergy.

Despite the award, Murphy-Myers said the case wasn’t about the money.

“It was about getting them to see, getting my voice heard — and the voices of all victims,” she said.

“For every voice that comes forward, there are 10 others too afraid to speak. So my voice is for those afraid to come forward.”

When Do I Need to Involve a Lawyer in My Insurance Claim?

October 24, 2022

When Do I Need to Involve a Lawyer in My Insurance Claim?

Do you know when you would need a personal injury lawyer to help with your insurance claim? Our latest blog breaks it down.

Read More
Experienced a Slip and Fall Accident? A Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help

October 3, 2022

Experienced a Slip and Fall Accident? A Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help

A slip and fall accident can have major consequences in various aspects of your life. While there is nothing that can undo the suffering that you have experienced, a personal injury lawyer can help to fight for compensation that you are entitled to as a result of your injuries.

Read More
Going To Trial vs. Settling In A Personal Injury Case

August 22, 2022

Going To Trial vs. Settling In A Personal Injury Case

In the event of legal dispute, is it better to go to trial or settle? Every case is unique, but our blog can help your learn about the advantages of either option.

Read More