'A beacon of hope': Catholic priests' appeal in sex-assault case rejected by Supreme Court

May 4, 2020

By: Nathaniel Basen, tvo.org

Beckett Personal Injury Office's Scales of Justice's article image

His lawyer, Rob Talach, was more effusive, “I’m just overjoyed. I’ve given the occasional hoot and holler in my house, and everyone thinks I’ve lost my marbles.”

This morning, the Supreme Court of Canada rejected an appeal from the Basilian Fathers of Toronto, bringing an end to a years’-long legal dispute. In April 2018, the Basilians were ordered to pay MacLeod just over $2.5 million, including $500,000 in punitive damages, stemming from a sexual-assault case in the 1960s. MacLeod was abused by Father Hodgson Marshall, then a Basilian priest, when MacLeod was a student at St. Charles College high school in Sudbury. During Marshall’s trial, in which he was found guilty of sexually abusing 17 victims, it was revealed that the Basilians had had at least three prior complaints about him prior to transferring him to St. Charles.

The story is the focus of Prey, an award-winning TVO Original documentary released last year.

“I’m not shy to say we were nervous,” says Talach. “You know, you always worry, the further you get from the folks who heard the evidence. And the more technical the arguments become, in my opinion, the more likely it is for an injustice to occur. So I know Rod and I both had very rough sleeps last night.”

“I was very nervous,” says MacLeod. “Because what they were asking for was a whole new trial, and anything can come out of a trial when you have to redo it all. Then it could be another couple of years before we get a resolution. So I was certainly concerned.”

The case could have far-reaching implications for victims of sexual assault. Talach says that two aspects of the decision are particularly critical. “First and flashiest,” he says, “is the fact that half a million dollars was taken from the Basilians as a sort of fine — what we call punitive damages. So the first thing this decision says is: if you’re an institution, and you engage in a cover-up or complicity in sexual abuse, you’re going to pay a big price tag. And that’s really significant, because there’s nothing in our criminal or regulatory law that really does that for us.” Second, he says, “it also clarified and established a lower legal test to prove economic loss in cases of sexual assault.”

“Rod is completely vindicated and victorious now,” Talach says. “There are no other legal routes of retreat or appeal for the Basilians here. It’s time for them to pay — it’s time for them to practise what they preach.”

MacLeod says he hopes this will act as a “beacon of hope for everyone that, in our wonderful country of Canada, you can get justice through the court system.”

For him, he says, this feels like the end of a dark chapter: “It’s finally been put to bed, and now I can go and sail around the world with [my partner] Carole. I’m going to go buy a boat.”

Published on April 30, 2020

Beckett Personal Injury Office In Downtown London

May 10, 2024

Enjoy A Safe And Happy Summer!

Summer is here! It’s time to kick back and relax a little. You may plan to invite people to your home for a barbeque or to your cottage for a weekend getaway. These can be great opportunities to de-stress and connect with those who are most important to you. When you do host, please serve alcohol responsibly to keep those people safe and ensure that you avoid a social host liability lawsuit.

Read More
Beckett Personal Injury Office In Downtown London

May 2, 2024

Importance of Motorcycle Safety

As the warmth of spring beckons, motorcycle enthusiasts prepare to rev up for the open road. But beyond the thrill lies a critical reminder: proper gear isn't just for style, it's for safety and legal protection. Discover why donning a helmet and protective clothing isn't just common sense—it's a legal necessity.

Read More
Beckett Personal Injury Office In Downtown London

May 2, 2024

Litigation Guardian 101

Discover the critical role of a Litigation Guardian in protecting the rights of those legally deemed "parties under disability". From understanding who qualifies as a party under disability to the complexities of guardianship selection, delve into the legal responsibilities and potential risks involved. Learn why being a Litigation Guardian requires careful consideration and informed decision-making, ensuring the best interests of the disabled party are upheld.

Read More