Disgraced Priest Dies a Prisoner

January 24, 2007

By: Jane Sims, London Free Press

Beckett Personal Injury Office's Scales of Justice's article image

was lying in almost a fetal position and a deep congestion had filled his chest.

"He was not coherent or conscious," said victim Carol Ann Mieras, who was abused when she was a member of Chatham's St. Ursula's parish and became the last victim to see Sylvestre alive.

"He was not able to answer any questions whatsoever. His pallor was very grey. His breathing was very laboured and he coughed a few times."

Mieras stood near his bed while video equipment was set up in futile hopes of taping a statement.

"It did seem as if the Grim Reaper was standing on his chest in the room waiting for him to go," she said.

Rob Talach, a London lawyer with Ledroit Beckett, also attended the meeting that was set up following a court order his firm sought because of concerns about Sylvestre's failing health. There were lawyers from several law firms, one for the diocese, one for Sylvestre and one for the Grey Nuns, who have been named in a civil action.

Talach said the room resembled a prison cell and Sylvestre's condition was "shocking."

"From the man I saw at the sentencing in October, I didn't even recognize him," Talach said. "He was unresponsive and physically atrophied."

Sylvestre's victims -- all of whom had suffered with the secret shame of sexual abuse by a trusted priest -- reacted with both shock and sadness.

Many said they felt sorrow for Sylvestre's family, particularly his sister in Belle River who had cared for him before he went to prison.

Chatham-Kent Crown attorney Paul Bailey said victim witness workers were on standby for any women who needed support.

"There's no joy in this for anybody," Bailey said. "The fact Father Sylvestre died in prison is just an additional layer of tragedy, which is spurring us on even more to work toward prevention."

At the time of Sylvestre's sentencing, many had viewed the three years as a life sentence for the frail octogenarian who had a variety of medical problems. He had been in the Kingston Regional Hospital -- part of Kingston Penitentiary -- for three days.

Corrections Canada spokesperson Diane Russon said Sylvestre had been in palliative care. He had been assessed to serve his sentence at the Bath medium-security prison, but "he never got there.

"I do believe family had been in to see him within the last days of his life," she said.

The correctional service will be conducting an internal investigation and a coroner's inquest will be ordered -- a standard practice.

Sylvestre's death marks the end of one chapter in a case that shocked the church community and pushed both London Bishop Ronald Fabbro and Sylvestre's victims to call for reforms within the church to stop the scourge of sexual abuse by priests.

But Sylvestre died as he lived -- a priest. His position remains unchanged, despite calls from both Fabbro and the community to have him de-frocked. The petition to have Sylvestre dismissed from the clerical state had been forwarded to Rome.

The diocese of London released a brief statement about his death yesterday and would not comment further.

"We continue to feel grief and shock at the revelations of his actions and we say again that we deplore all instances of sexual abuse and sexual impropriety, especially by clergy or anyone in the Church's employ, towards minors," the statement said.

Fabbro directed all parishes to pray for Sylvestre's victims, their families and supporters and for Sylvestre's family and "for the repose of his soul."

Funeral arrangements were not complete and it is expected Sylvestre's funeral will be private.

The Steps to Proving Negligence in a Personal Injury Claim

December 18, 2024

The Steps to Proving Negligence in a Personal Injury Claim

Proving negligence is often one of the main requirements in personal injury claims. Negligence refers to a failure to act with the reasonable care that a person or entity owes to others. In this blog, we’ll discuss the four requirements needed to prove negligence and receive compensation in a personal injury claim.

Read More
Addressing the Impact of Clergy Sexual Abuse: A Path Toward Healing and Accountability

December 12, 2024

Addressing the Impact of Clergy Sexual Abuse: A Path Toward Healing and Accountability

Clergy sexual abuse is a grave and deeply troubling issue that has impacted countless individuals and communities worldwide. The abuse of power and trust by religious leaders has left scars that are not easily healed. In the wake of these crimes, both the victims and society as a whole must grapple with the consequences of such profound violations. Addressing the impact of clergy sexual abuse requires not only acknowledging the pain it has caused but also taking actionable steps toward accountability, justice, and healing for all involved.

Read More
How to be Successful at Mediation

December 11, 2024

How to be Successful at Mediation

Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution. It is a means for people to settle disputes or lawsuits outside of court. Most people don’t want to go to court. A neutral third party—the mediator—helps the disputing parties look for a solution that works for them. Mediators, unlike judges, do not decide the case. The mediator's role is simply to help the people involved in a dispute to negotiate with each other in a constructive manner, to gain a better understanding of the interests of all parties, and to find a resolution based on common understanding and mutual agreement.

Read More